Recently the question "Why do some SDHC cards have extra contacts?" was closed as off-topic. While I agree that the original question was off topic, there was some debate as to whether the question would be on topic if specifically in the context of asking if the extra contacts had any impact on Photographic uses of the card.

Should this question be on topic if it was rephrased to something along the lines of "do these extra pins on my SD Card have any impact on how the card will perform in my camera?"

To be clear, this is specifically asking if the revised form of the question would have been on topic if it was the original question. I'm not looking for if we should edit a question that is bad that could have some value if modified, but rather if the modified version actually has value.

Recently the question "Why do some SDHC cards have extra contacts?" was closed as off-topic. While I agree that the original question was off topic, there was some debate as to whether the question would be on topic if specifically in the context of asking if the extra contacts had any impact on Photographic uses of the card.

Should this question be on topic if it was rephrased to something along the lines of "do these extra pins on my SD Card have any impact on how the card will perform in my camera?"

To be clear, this is specifically asking if the revised form of the question would have been on topic if it was the original question. I'm not looking for if we should edit a question that is bad that could have some value if modified, but rather if the modified version actually has value.

Recently the question "Why do some SDHC cards have extra contacts?" was closed as off-topic. While I agree that the original question was off topic, there was some debate as to whether the question would be on topic if specifically in the context of asking if the extra contacts had any impact on Photographic uses of the card.

Should this question be on topic if it was rephrased to something along the lines of "do these extra pins on my SD Card have any impact on how the card will perform in my camera?"

Recently the question "Why do some SDHC cards have extra contacts?" was closed as off-topic. While I agree that the original question was off topic, there was some debate as to whether the question would be on topic if specifically in the context of asking if the extra contacts had any impact on Photographic uses of the card.

Should this question be on topic if it was rephrased to something along the lines of "do these extra pins on my SD Card have any impact on how the card will perform in my camera?"

To be clear, this is specifically asking if the revised form of the question would have been on topic if it was the original question. I'm not looking for if we should edit a question that is bad that could have some value if modified, but rather if the modified version actually has value.