5

Since there's no reputation reward or stack-exchange virtual stickers for it, I'm using this space to say thanks to @scottbb for valiant effort to save the tag, by making it refer to actual, real-world filters rather than digital post-processing filters. This is a bit quixotic, but, hey — it does make the thing a bit more useful than having it as a mess of "effect" and physical filter questions mixed together.

People are still gonna keep coming by and using it for Instagram questions (or, you know, "What filter do I need to take pictures like I saw in National Geographic?" — *sigh*), though, so we will need to either keep a constant eye on it, or come up with some non-ambiguous synonym and use that instead. I don't have any ideas though, so... opening discussion. :)

  • upvoted. obviously =) – scottbb Jul 10 '16 at 1:46
1

First pitch: either or .

I like [app-filters] because it's shorter, and frankly, 95% of the people who will be asking this will be about apps like Instagram, followed by Facebook, Photos, and a smattering of VSCO and others.

The pro for [software-filters] is that it also applies to desktop software "filters" (I don't know about others, but to me, "apps" means smartphone/tablet software. Maybe I'm a curmudgeon).

Agreed, this will be a constant PITA, however, because new users will always be coming in with "what filter did so-and-so use in this picture?" arggh.

  • 2
    More inclined to [digital-filters] to be honest. – John Cavan Jul 10 '16 at 14:55
  • The others could be a tag synonym in that event. Still requires some diligence on our part, but it's a start. – John Cavan Jul 10 '16 at 14:56
  • @JohnCavan [digital-filters] is pretty good. I'm personally just slightly adverse to it because I come from a digital signal processing background, where "digital filtering" goes hand-in-hand with Z-transforms. But I'd happily give up that ground if it means protecting [filters] for the physical ones. =) – scottbb Jul 10 '16 at 16:58
  • The problem I have is that people are still going to use "filters" for software effects, and we'll have to retag. Maybe that just can't be helped. – mattdm Jul 10 '16 at 19:04
  • 2
    @mattdm Yep. That's the conclusion I came to awhile ago. There's really only 2 options: sweep-up duty; or giving up the tag to the "what's this effect called" Instagram crowd, and retreating to something like [physical-filters]. I really don't like the 2nd option. – scottbb Jul 10 '16 at 19:07

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .