Shouldn't a link to chat be the first thing we would offer a new user who asks something like this? At times it seems like we want to run new people off! We obviously have no trouble telling a new user why "we don't/can't do that here" but apparently we don't know how to post a link to chat...


No, it's not against any policy to be helpful.

Here's some helpful information: users with less than 20 reputation points cannot talk in chat.

  • Thanks for that helpful tidbit. I can't remember ever not being able to post in chat. I guess I already had 20 points the first time I tried.
    – Michael C
    Mar 1 '18 at 3:28
  • Can a lower rep user participate in a specific chat room created for that user and a few others, rather than the general chat room for each SE site?
    – Michael C
    Mar 1 '18 at 3:28
  • 2
    Only a diamond-carrying moderator can lift the restriction (for a specific user in a specific room), the process is described here.
    – user37753
    Mar 1 '18 at 3:45
  • @FTP also converting comments to chat will also add the user automatically, but spawning a list of however many comments it takes to activate that probably isn't an ideal work around.
    – AJ Henderson Mod
    Mar 2 '18 at 5:11

Current advice (from my limited perspective) seems to be to give constructive feedback when downvoting. FWIW - I'm posting this 13 hours after you asked, and the question is already gone.

Perhaps the policy should be to put a little extra effort in when the question is being asked by a 1 rep user. For Example:

  • Don't downvote without a comment
  • If the comment is "this doesn't belong here" - then answer the question, where does it belong and how can I help OP get there?

I guess it comes back to goals. But, if a goal is to add additional, active users to the community, then the policy needs to reflect a bit more help to new users. Or at least, avoidance of some of the immediate hostility.

A link to chat would be great, if only it were a universal privilege. (My chat privileges were granted by the system not that long ago)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .